Three bottles of Firstleaf wine on a purple table with an orange background; a Firstleaf box and a fruit platter.

Top Award Winning Wines

Bring your best bottle to the table. Our top award winning wines boast impressive accolades from competitions and critics worldwide. Whether you're looking for a prize-winning white, stand-out red, or remarkable rosé, this exceptional selection has just what you need.

SHOWING 155 RESULTS

Filter by:

Sort by:

  • Recommended
  • Customer Ratings
  • Price: High to Low
  • Price: Low to High
  • Name: A-Z
  • Name: Z-A
    • Special Award medal
    • 94 points medal
    • Gold medal award

    Olive medal award Winner of 7 more

    Fine Wine Collection

    Loudspeaker

    2023 Meritage Red from Napa Valley, United States

    Uncorking a concert of flavor in every bottle

    View wine details

    $68.40 Retail price

    $47.88 Member price

    • 90 points medal
    • Gold medal award
    • Silver medal award

    Rancho Campo

    2023 Bonarda from Valle de Uco / Uco Valley, Argentina

    A lightly sweet release from steadfast Rancho Campo

    View wine details

    $33.50 Retail price

    $23.45 Member price

    • 90 points medal
    • Gold medal award
    • Silver medal award
    Fine Wine Collection

    Weelderige Velde

    2024 Syrah from Coastal Region, South Africa

    An uncompromising dedication to craft—a convergence of structure and nuance

    View wine details

    $54.00 Retail price

    $37.80 Member price

    • Gold medal award
    • Silver medal award

    Common Phenomena

    2023 Red Blend from Paso Robles, United States

    Bright pomegranate and blackcurrant layered with earthy complexity

    View wine details

    $32.50 Retail price

    $22.75 Member price

    • 91 points medal
    • Silver medal award

    Olive medal award Winner of 1 more

    Quedarse

    2024 Sauvignon Blanc from Spain, Spain

    Citrus and sun-kissed fruit linger, inviting you to stay and sip.

    View wine details

    $27.00 Retail price

    $18.90 Member price

    • 92 points medal
    • Gold medal award

    Olive medal award Winner of 3 more

    Libellus

    2024 Red Blend from Italy, Italy

    Rustic earth and supple fruit harmonize in this smooth, savory pour

    View wine details

    $30.50 Retail price

    $21.35 Member price

    • Special Award medal
    • 98 points medal
    • Gold medal award

    Olive medal award Winner of 3 more

    Masterworks Series

    2024 Vino Tinto from Spain, Spain

    Artistry meets the vine with a blend of berries and chocolate for gatherings

    View wine details

    $26.50 Retail price

    $18.55 Member price

    • Silver medal award
    • Bronze medal award

    Cassiday Blare

    2024 White Blend from Lodi, United States

    Bright citrus, bold character—this white was born to break the rules

    View wine details

    $29.50 Retail price

    $20.65 Member price

    • Gold medal award

    Ophidian

    2024 Rosé from Coastal Region, South Africa

    A hypnotic swirl of ripe papaya and sun-kissed berries, flowing with elegance

    View wine details

    $29.00 Retail price

    $20.30 Member price

    • 91 points medal
    • Silver medal award
    • Bronze medal award

    Milieux

    2023 Lightly Sweet Zinfandel from Lodi, United States

    Red apple, caramel, cinnamon, and herbs blend for this smooth crowd-pleaser

    View wine details

    $29.25 Retail price

    $20.47 Member price

    • Special Award medal
    • 98 points medal
    • Silver medal award

    Olive medal award Winner of 2 more

    Fine Wine Collection

    Loquet

    2024 Rhône-style Red Wine Syrah-Grenache-Viognier from Coastal Region, South Africa

    A meeting of legacy and landscape—Old World finesse embraces New World vitality

    View wine details

    $54.00 Retail price

    $37.80 Member price

    • Silver medal award

    Lazy Breeze

    2022 Lightly Sweet Chardonnay from California, United States

    Perfect for that impromptu girl's brunch at home

    View wine details

    $25.75 Retail price

    $18.02 Member price

    • Gold medal award
    • Silver medal award

    Olive medal award Winner of 1 more

    Maiden's Delight

    2023 Pinot Grigio from Italy, Italy

    Crisp lemon, green apple, and pear notes refresh with every lively sip

    View wine details

    $25.50 Retail price

    $17.85 Member price

    • Silver medal award

    Olive medal award Winner of 2 more

    Luxana

    2023 Rosé from Clarksburg, United States

    Where effortless elegance meets lingering flavors

    View wine details

    $26.50 Retail price

    $18.55 Member price

    • 91 points medal
    • Bronze medal award

    Every Cloud

    2023 Pinot Grigio from California, United States

    Perfect for sunny afternoons with friends, savoring carefree California charm

    View wine details

    $25.50 Retail price

    $17.85 Member price

    • Silver medal award
    • Bronze medal award

    Olive medal award Winner of 1 more

    Fine Wine Collection

    Tarreñas Sombras

    2024 Carménère - Carignan from Chile, Chile

    Rooted in the earth, layered in complexity—taste the soul of Chile's soil

    View wine details

    $57.60 Retail price

    $40.32 Member price

Keep Reading About Top Award Winning Wines

How do wine critics find the best wines?

In order to receive recognition, wines are commonly entered in wine competitions. During these events, wines are tasted and evaluated by a panel of expert judges, otherwise known as wine critics. The process typically involves the following steps:

  1. Submissions: Wineries submit their wines to the competition, specifying the category or style for each entry.
  2. Tasting: The wines are often presented to the judges in a blind-tasting format during the competition. This means they do not know the winery they are evaluating, so they can remain impartial.
  3. Evaluation: Judges assess the wines based on a set of criteria, including appearance, aroma, flavor, body, balance and finish. They assign scores or ratings to each wine.
  4. Medals and Awards: Wines that meet specific quality standards are awarded medals, such as gold, silver, or bronze, depending on their scores. They also earn a numerical rating on a 100-point scale, with the best wines earning over 90 points. Some competitions may grant special awards, like "Best in Show" or "Best Varietal."

Wine competitions and critics play an important role in recognizing excellence, helping wine lovers choose what to drink and providing valuable feedback for winemakers. However, it's your personal preference and opinion that matter most. While awards can be helpful if you're struggling to select a bottle, you should feel confident in wines you like, regardless of their award status. Never hesitate to try something new, even if it hasn't caught a critic's eye. The wine world is filled with hidden treasures. The best way to find new favorites is to let your palate be your guide as you explore unfamiliar regions and producers worldwide.